# Overe - OCaml Port of Vere (Urbit Runtime)

## Project Goal

Port the Vere (Urbit C runtime) to OCaml piece by piece, starting with core components and comparing performance against the original C implementation.

## Completed Work

### 1. Nock Interpreter (`lib/nock.ml`)

**Status**: ✅ Complete and tested

- Implemented complete Nock interpreter with all 12 opcodes
- Direct port of `_n_nock_on` from C implementation in `pkg/noun/nock.c`
- Uses Zarith (GMP-backed) for arbitrary-precision integers
- All test cases pass (`test/test_nock.ml`)

**Key Functions**:
- `nock_on`: Main interpreter loop
- `slot`: Tree addressing using bit notation
- All 12 opcodes: 0 (slot), 1 (constant), 2 (nock), 3 (cell test), 4 (increment), 5 (equality), 6 (if-then-else), 7 (compose), 8 (push), 9 (call), 10 (hint), 11 (wish/deprecated)

### 2. Performance Benchmarking

**Status**: ✅ Complete with detailed results

Created comprehensive benchmark suite comparing C vs OCaml:
- `bench_nock.ml`: OCaml benchmarks
- `bench_simple.c`: Standalone C implementation for comparison
- `compare.sh`: Comparison script
- `BENCHMARKS.md`: Full results documentation

**Key Findings**:
- C is 2-5x faster on average
- OCaml is competitive or faster on allocation-heavy operations
- OCaml shows more consistent performance (less variance)
- For decrement: C 1.39x faster
- For tree navigation: C 4.87x faster
- For nock(decrement): OCaml 1.12x faster
- For deep recursion: C 2.41x faster

### 3. Noun Type System (`lib/noun.ml`)

**Status**: ✅ Complete

```ocaml
type noun =
  | Atom of Z.t
  | Cell of noun * noun
```

Helper functions:
- `atom`, `cell`: Constructors
- `is_atom`, `is_cell`: Type predicates
- `head`, `tail`: Cell accessors
- `slot`: Tree addressing (axis addressing)
- `atom_to_int`, `noun_to_string`: Conversions

### 4. Bitstream Utilities (`lib/bitstream.ml`)

**Status**: ✅ Complete

Implements bit-level reading/writing for jam/cue serialization:

**Writer**:
```ocaml
type writer = {
  buf: bytes ref;
  mutable bit_pos: int;
}
```
- `writer_create()`: Initialize writer
- `write_bit`: Write single bit
- `write_bits`: Write multiple bits from a Z.t value
- `writer_to_bytes`: Extract final bytes
- `writer_ensure`: Dynamic buffer resizing

**Reader**:
```ocaml
type reader = {
  bytes: bytes;
  mutable bit_pos: int;
}
```
- `reader_create`: Initialize from bytes
- `read_bit`: Read single bit
- `read_bits`: Read multiple bits into Z.t
- `reader_pos`: Get current bit position

**Critical Fix**: OCaml operator precedence issue
- Problem: `!(w.buf)` parsed as `(!w).buf`
- Solution: Use intermediate variable pattern:
  ```ocaml
  let buf_ref : bytes ref = w.buf in
  let buf : bytes = !buf_ref in
  ```

### 5. Jam/Cue Serialization (`lib/serial.ml`)

**Status**: 🔴 IN PROGRESS - Has bugs

Implementation of noun serialization with backreference compression.

**Jam Encoding Format**:
- Atoms: tag bit `0`, then mat-encoded value
- Cells: tag bits `01`, then recursively encode head and tail
- Backrefs: tag bits `11`, then mat-encoded position

**Mat Encoding** (variable-length integers):
- For 0: single `0` bit
- For n > 0:
  - a = bit-width of n (`Z.numbits n`)
  - b = bit-width of a
  - Write b `1`-bits, then one `0`-bit
  - Write a in b-1 bits
  - Write n in a bits

**Current Implementation**:
```ocaml
let mat_encode w n =
  if Z.equal n Z.zero then
    write_bit w false
  else begin
    let a = Z.numbits n in
    let b = Z.numbits (Z.of_int a) in
    for _i = 1 to b do write_bit w true done;
    write_bit w false;
    write_bits w (Z.of_int a) (b - 1);  (* Write a, not a-1 *)
    write_bits w n a
  end
```

**Known Bugs**:
1. ✅ Fixed: mat_encode for 0 wrote `true` instead of `false`
2. ✅ Fixed: Was writing `a-1` in `b-1` bits, changed to `a` based on C code analysis
3. 🔴 **CURRENT BUG**: Roundtrip test passes for 0,1,2,3 but fails at 4
   - Test shows: `FAIL: 4 -> 0`
   - Need to compare against actual Urbit jam output to find discrepancy

**Test Status** (`test/test_serial.ml`):
- Atom roundtrip: FAILS at value 4
- Basic jam/cue: Not yet fully validated

### 6. Python Urbit Interface (`urb.py`)

**Status**: ✅ Updated to Python 3

Script to communicate with running Urbit ship via lens port. Can be used to get correct jam/cue test vectors.

**Changes Made**:
- Shebang: `#!/usr/bin/env python3`
- String decoding: `.encode().decode('unicode_escape')`
- File write: mode `'wb'` for binary
- Logging: `warn` → `warning`
- Idiom: `'X' not in dict`

**Usage** (needs running Urbit ship):
```bash
python3 urb.py -d "(jam 42)"    # Get jam encoding of 42
python3 urb.py -d "(cue 42)"    # Decode jam encoding
```

## Project Structure

```
ocaml/
├── dune-project          # Project configuration (package: overe)
├── lib/
│   ├── dune             # Library stanza
│   ├── noun.ml          # Noun type system
│   ├── nock.ml          # Nock interpreter
│   ├── bitstream.ml     # Bit-level I/O
│   └── serial.ml        # Jam/cue serialization
├── test/
│   ├── dune             # Test executables
│   ├── test_nock.ml     # Nock tests (all passing)
│   └── test_serial.ml   # Jam/cue tests (failing at 4)
├── tmp/                 # Temporary test files
├── urb.py              # Python script to query Urbit ship
├── BENCHMARKS.md       # Performance comparison results
└── CLAUDE.md           # This file
```

## Next Steps

### Immediate Priority: Fix Jam/Cue Bug

1. **Get test vectors from Urbit**:
   ```bash
   python3 urb.py -d "(jam 0)"
   python3 urb.py -d "(jam 1)"
   python3 urb.py -d "(jam 2)"
   python3 urb.py -d "(jam 3)"
   python3 urb.py -d "(jam 4)"  # This is where OCaml fails
   ```

2. **Compare OCaml output**:
   - Create test program to print hex output of jam for 0-10
   - Compare against Urbit's output byte-by-byte
   - Identify exact discrepancy in mat encoding

3. **Fix mat_decode**:
   - Ensure it matches the corrected mat_encode formula
   - Currently may be reading `a-1` when it should read `a`

### Future Work

1. **Complete Jam/Cue**:
   - Fix current bugs
   - Add comprehensive tests
   - Benchmark performance vs C

2. **Memory Management**:
   - Implement noun hash-consing/deduplication
   - Add reference counting or GC integration
   - Study u3 memory system from C implementation

3. **Jets**:
   - Port jet dashboard system
   - Implement critical jets for performance
   - Add jet registration and lookup

4. **Persistence**:
   - Implement snapshot system
   - Port event log handling
   - Add checkpoint/restore functionality

## Build Instructions

```bash
# Build library and tests
dune build

# Run Nock tests (all passing)
dune exec test/test_nock.exe

# Run jam/cue tests (currently failing at 4)
dune exec test/test_serial.exe

# Query running Urbit (requires ship running on port 12323 or with .http.ports)
python urb.py -d "(jam 42)"
```

## Technical Notes

### OCaml Challenges Encountered

1. **Operator precedence with refs**: `!(r.field)` doesn't work, need intermediate variable
2. **Zarith numbits**: Returns actual bit count, not bit index (e.g., 4 needs 3 bits, `numbits` returns 3)
3. **Mutable fields**: Need to use `mutable` keyword and assignment operator `:=`
4. **Bytes are mutable**: Use `Bytes.sub` to copy, not share

### Mat Encoding Details from C Code

From `pkg/noun/serial.c` line 126:
```c
// Write a_w (the width) in b_w-1 bits
u3r_chop(0, 0, b_w - 1, 0, &a_w, &bits);
```

This writes `a` (the width), NOT `a-1`. The OCaml implementation has been updated to match this.

### References

- Vere C implementation: `/home/y/code/urbit/vere/pkg/`
- Nock specification: https://urbit.org/docs/nock/reference/
- Jam/cue format: See official Urbit docs (provided in conversation)
- u3 system architecture: See docs on king/serf, jets, persistence

## Performance Philosophy

Goal is not to beat C in raw speed, but to:
- Provide maintainable, type-safe implementation
- Enable experimentation with runtime features
- Achieve competitive performance on real workloads
- Leverage OCaml's strengths (allocation, GC, pattern matching)

Current results show this is achievable: OCaml is within 2-5x of C, and actually faster for some allocation-heavy operations.